Learning · Compare
Tank vs Tankless
They both heat water, but very differently. Here are the honest pros and cons of each, so you can decide if tankless is worth it for you.
At a glance
| Tank | Gas tankless | |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Lower, and installation costs less | Higher; piping may need rerouting |
| Energy use | Keeps 40 to 75 gallons hot around the clock | Heats only when you need it |
| Hot water | Runs out, then has to recover | Endless when sized right |
| Space | Large, and new tanks are wider | Compact and wall-mounted |
| Lifespan | 8 to 12 years | 20 years or more with maintenance |
| Maintenance | Annual flush | Annual descaling in hard water |
Installed prices for both are on our prices page.
Tank water heaters
Pros: lower cost, easy replacement
Tanks are not as efficient as gas tankless, but they cost less overall and cost less to install. Usually you replace the tank with the same size unit. New federal energy standards have made tanks wider, though, so a professional has to make sure the new one fits the existing space.
Con: higher energy costs
Because the hot water is stored, the burner or elements run more than a tankless to hold it at 125 to 130°F, whether you need hot water or not.
Con: you can run out of hot water
Once the tank is used up, there is no more hot water until it recovers. This happens when several people or appliances use hot water at once.
Con: takes up more space
A tank needs room, and energy standards have made new tanks wider for extra insulation. Ask us how this affects your replacement.
Con: shorter life
In Valley hard water a tank typically lasts 8 to 12 years; a gas tankless lasts 20 years or more with maintenance.
Gas tankless water heaters
Pro: never run out of hot water
Back-to-back showers with no wait to reheat, and you can shower while the dishwasher or washing machine runs. Extremely effective for larger families.
Pro: low energy costs
A tankless heats water only when you need it. Think of the energy it takes to keep 40, 50 or 75 gallons hot all day: that adds up.
Pro: less space, more room
Because new tanks are wider, a same-size replacement may not fit where your old one stood. That alone has many homeowners considering tankless.
Pro: a longer life
Maintained properly, a tankless can last about twice as long as a tank.
Con: higher installation cost
Installation costs more than a tank, and some piping may need rerouting. Call (602) 833-1533 for free advice and helpful hints.
Con: more maintenance
A tankless is compact but has more internal parts. In Phoenix hard water it needs descaling once a year, or a water softener or scale inhibitor to slow the scale.
Tankless Pros AZ
Weighing your options?
- Free advice and helpful hints by phone
- We check whether a new, wider tank fits your space
- You see both options side by side before you decide
Mon - Sat, 7:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Keep reading
Related guides.
-
TanklessPros & cons of a tanklessAn honest review of gas tankless for Phoenix homes. -
UpgradesWhen to upgradeSeven signs it is time to replace a tank with a tankless. -
TanklessHow a tankless worksStep by step inside a Navien NPE-A2 condensing tankless. -
ReplacementWater heater ageRead the age from the serial number and know when to replace.
Free quote
Compare both options, free.
Quick 15 minute or less reply. Mon - Sat, 7:00 AM - 7:00 PM.